SuperCoach AFL 2024: 5 finest defenders to select in 2024, Nick Daicos, James Sicily, Tom Stewart

Everyone knows the saying, defence wins premierships.

Stingy, hard-nosed gamers that solely fear about conserving their direct opponent quiet with lunging spoils and determined defensive efforts are so necessary to AFL sides.

In SuperCoach, we’re not so .

There are different defenders who run off their opponent to get further disposals, cruise throughout half again by themselves taking intercept marks and transfer into the midfield at occasions for centre bounces.

Now that’s extra what we’re searching for.

This 12 months there are a plethora of choices to your staff, with Luke Ryan, Jack Sinclair and Harry Sheezel not even making this checklist.

Listed here are 5 defenders to think about in SuperCoach this 12 months.

NICK DAICOS $650,000

Recent from averaging 116.3 in simply his second 12 months, Daicos now has dual-position standing supplying you with flexibility to maneuver footy’s largest identify from defence to midfield and again once more. What potential motive might there be to not begin Nick Daicos? Effectively turns on the market are a pair. The star Magpie is taking part in in Opening Spherical which implies he has an early bye in spherical 5. Previous to that he comes up in opposition to tagger Finn Maginness in spherical 4, who had his quantity when the Pies met the Hawks final 12 months.

Verdict: The great outweighs the unhealthy with Daicos and also you’ll need him in your ultimate staff. It’s solely a query of whether or not you begin the Brownlow fancy or take a threat and intention to commerce him in after his first bye.


Sicily took the Hawthorn captaincy in his stride final season, averaging a profession excessive in SuperCoach and incomes his first All-Australian blazer. His intercepting means is rivalled by only a few and the Hawks love the ball in his arms popping out of the again half. Sicily’s solely concern is staying away from hassle, as suspension put him on the sidelines for 4 matches in 2023.

Verdict: A participant with a large ceiling as evidenced by scores of 172, 171 and 166 final 12 months. For those who don’t decide Sicily, he’ll make you jealous of those that did when opposition groups regularly kick the ball down his throat.

TOM STEWART $635,300

The premiership Cat seems to be more likely to step up his midfield minutes in 2023 and that brings each positives and negatives. Stewart scored the second most factors of any defender final 12 months, predominantly taking part in as an interceptor off half again. Whereas Stewart will lose out on a few of these intercept marks in defence if he steps up into the midfield, he’ll acquire factors being consistently across the ball at stoppages. Within the quick period of time Stewart has performed midfield the 30-year outdated scored at an analogous if not higher price as he did taking part in within the backline.

Verdict: Some could also be cautious of his function change, however whether or not he performs down again or within the guts Stewart has confirmed he can pile on loads of SuperCoach factors.


I couldn’t not point out this bloke with Tim Michell sitting throughout from me. Tim’s determined 2024 is the 12 months of Hayden Younger. The Docker completed final season with 4 110-plus scores after transferring into the midfield and that pattern is about to proceed this 12 months. Younger additionally earned a bit of factors through tackles in that month of soccer which is gold in SuperCoach.

Verdict: The 22-year outdated is greater than $100,000 cheaper than uber premium choices in Daicos, Sicily and Stewart. I’m gonna take Tim’s recommendation and begin him.


After lacking all the 2023 season with an ACL damage, Zac Williams is an absolute discount purchase this 12 months. The final time the previous Large put collectively greater than a 14-game season, he averaged 101.6 factors throughout 20 matches in 2019. Sure that was 5 years in the past, however Williams has confirmed he can rating properly in SuperCoach and at that juicy value of $216,100 he should be in calculations to your staff.

Verdict: Majority will begin with Williams and cop his spherical 2 bye, however his value received’t change till after his third sport in spherical 3. For those who commerce him in previous to that match, you’ll solely miss out on one sport value of Williams’ scoring given Opening Spherical doesn’t rely. Meals for thought.

Initially printed as SuperCoach: 5 defenders to think about to your staff in 2024